12 Must Eat Places in Siesta Key, Florida
Nestled on the sandy shores of Florida, Siesta Key is a paradise not only for its picturesque beaches but also as a sanctuary for food lovers. In this blog post, we’ll take you on a gastronomic tour of Siesta Key’s top eateries where the flavors are as magnificent as the sunset views.
From freshly caught seafood to mouthwatering BBQ and inventive cocktails, Siesta Key is a foodie haven with a variety of dining experiences to suit every taste. Prepare for a flavor-packed voyage as we introduce the culinary stars of this coastal gem.
1. Spearfish Grille
- Website
- Address: 1265 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
- Best Menu Items: Hogfish, Coconut Shrimp, Sushi Tacos
At Spearfish Grille, we celebrate the ocean’s treasures every single day. Ever tried hogfish? It’s a crowd favorite! Give the Hogfish Taco or Hogfish Sandwich a go. The restaurant catches it daily, so you’re in for the freshest seafood treat!
There are several local beers on tap, ask the servers what they have! Save room for dessert, because they have some amazing options. There is Florida’s classic key lime pie, mud pie, or pineapple upside down cake. You can’t go wrong with whatever you choose!
2. The Cottage
- Website
- Address: 153 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242
- Best Menu Items: Short Rib Bites, Lobster Bisque, Grouper Sandwich
The beauty of beachfront dining is embodied at The Cottage. Their award-winning crab cakes have garnered acclaim far and wide, promising a satisfying crunch and succulent meat with every bite. It’s a charming escape for those seeking to dine with the sound of waves in the background.
3. The Old Salty Dog
- Website
- Address: 5023 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242
- Best Menu Items: Hot Dogs, Fish and Chips, Coconut Shrimp
An institution in Siesta Key, The Old Salty Dog presents a no-frills approach to delicious comfort food. Bite into their renowned “Salty Dog” hot dog while soaking up the relaxed, come-as-you-are vibe that patrons love.
The menu has many standout items, including the loaded hot dogs, lobster rolls, and grouper fish tacos. There are also plenty of colorful and flavorful drinks to choose from!
With live music and outdoor seating, it’s the perfect spot to unwind after a day at the beach. And yes, dogs are welcome here!
4. Ripfire Pizza & BBQ
- Website
- Address: 5218 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242
- Best Menu Items: Pulled Pork, Caesar Salad, BBQ Chicken Pizza
For pizza aficionados and BBQ enthusiasts alike, Ripfire Pizza & BBQ satisfies cravings with their exceptional wood-fired pizzas and succulent, slow-cooked BBQ meats. It’s a harmonious melding of fire-kissed flavor you won’t want to miss.
In addition to their mouthwatering food, Ripfire also offers a wide selection of craft beers and cocktails to complement your meal.
Try their signature BBQ pizza or create your own from a variety of toppings, and don’t forget to finish it off with an indulgent dessert pizza.
5. Island House Tap and Grill
- Website
- Address: 5110 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL 34242
- Best Menu Items: Tuna Tacos, Lobster Tacos, and Grouper Tacos
Island House Tap and Grill boasts a curated collection of craft beers to dazzle the discerning drinker. Pair your brew with a the Island House tacos or even a burger and fries—and you’ve got the perfect casual dining experience.
Featuring live music and outdoor seating, this laid-back spot is the ideal hangout to unwind with friends or family. And with a diverse menu of burgers, sandwiches, salads, and more, there’s something for everyone at Island House Tap and Grill.
6. The Hub Baja Grill
- Website
- Address: 5148 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242
- Best Menu Items: Grouper Sandwich, Grouper Tacos, Lobster Bisque
Get a taste of the vibrant Mexican coastline at The Hub Baja Grill, where the Grouper Tacos reign supreme. This award-winning restaurant also offers a variety of traditional and fusion Mexican dishes, all made with fresh ingredients and bold flavors.
With its lively atmosphere and outdoor seating, The Hub is the perfect spot to enjoy a margarita and some delicious food while taking in the ocean views. And for seafood lovers, their famous Seafood Tower is an absolute must-try.
Be sure to check out their daily specials and live music nights for an even more memorable dining experience.
7. The Lobster Pot
- Website
- Address: 5157 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242
- Best Menu Items: Lobster Roll, Cornbread, Clam Chowder
The Lobster Pot is a real gem for seafood lovers, offering a fantastic menu that really celebrates ocean delicacies. You’ve got to try their Lobster Bisque or Clam Chowder – they’re amazing and really show off the fancy side of dining by the sea. And their famous Lobster Roll is a must-try – packed with fresh lobster meat and served on a buttery toasted bun.
With its relaxed atmosphere and ocean-inspired decor, The Lobster Pot is the perfect spot for a casual seafood feast.
8. Gilligan’s Island Bar & Grill
At Gilligan’s Island Bar & Grill, it’s all about those Caribbean vibes. Grab a Rum Runner cocktail and let the island-themed chill wash over you.
You must try the Fish Sandwiches – they’re a hit! And trust me, the Pina Colada is as refreshing as it gets. Gilligan’s is super laid-back and the crew is all about friendly vibes, making it the perfect place to hang with friends after a beach day. Oh, and you definitely want to be there on live music nights.
9. Siesta Key Oyster Bar
If you’re craving oysters that taste like they’ve just been plucked from the sea, you’ve gotta hit up Siesta Key Oyster Bar. It’s the perfect place to chill, enjoy some fresh oysters in the open, and groove to live music.
And if oysters aren’t your thing, no worries – there’s loads of other tasty stuff on the menu.
Definitely try the Shrimp Tacos and Grouper Bites – they’re a hit with both locals and tourists. The place has this awesome energy and the seafood is to die for, making it a must-visit spot for any seafood enthusiast!
10. Summer House Steak & Seafood
- Website
- Address: 149 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242
- Best Menu Items: Lobster Bisque, Oysters Rockefeller, Porterhouse Steak
Craving a delicious surf and turf? Swing by Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood for some wood-grilled steaks and the freshest seafood around. They’re pros at both land and sea dishes, promising a fantastic meal every time you visit.
The lobster bisque, Oysters Rockefeller, and that Porterhouse steak really stand out on the menu. But don’t forget to leave some room for their famous Key Lime Pie!
With a charming interior inspired by the classic beach houses of Siesta Key, this restaurant offers a cozy and intimate atmosphere where you can enjoy a delicious meal with your loved ones.
11. Village Cafe
- Website
- Address: 5133 Ocean Blvd, Siesta Key, FL 34242
- Best Menu Items: Omelettes, Pancakes, Breakfast Nachos, Mimosas
Village Cafe is a local favorite, and for good reason. This quaint spot offers a menu filled with delicious breakfast and brunch options, as well as tasty lunch bites.
Try their famous Village French Toast or indulge in one of their specialty omelets. For lunch, the sandwiches and salads are always fresh and flavorful.
Enjoy your meal while sitting on the outdoor patio, surrounded by the tropical landscape of Siesta Key. And don’t forget to grab one of their freshly baked pastries on your way out!
12. Big Water Fish Market
- Website
- Address: 6639 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242
- Best Menu Items: Grouper Reuben Sandwich, Hush Puppies
If you’re a seafood lover, this is the place for you. Big Water Fish Market offers a variety of fresh fish and shellfish from local waters, including their famous lobster rolls and daily specials.
This market-style restaurant also has an outdoor seating area where you can enjoy your meal under the warm Florida sun. Don’t miss out on their delicious peel-and-eat shrimp or the mouthwatering fish tacos.
But if you prefer to cook your seafood at home, they also have a market section where you can purchase fresh catches and seafood dishes to go.
Siesta Key’s food scene is as wide-ranging and inviting as its beach views. Whether you’re after a fancy dinner or just a casual bite by the water, there’s something here for everyone.
Come enjoy the warm breezes, stunning views, and amazing flavors in Siesta Key, Florida. Can’t wait to see you here. Bon appétit!
