10 Restaurants in Florida Renowned for Their Key Lime Pie

Key lime pie isn’t just dessert in Florida—it’s a way of life. With its perfect mix of tart and sweet, creamy filling, and buttery crust, this iconic pie deserves more than a quick mention. It’s worth a full-on foodie pilgrimage. You’ll find key lime pie all over the state, but the best versions come from places that truly understand the art of balancing real key lime juice with just the right touch of sweetness.

We’ve rounded up the top spots for key lime pie, based on travel reviews, food critic picks, and recommendations from locals who know their pie. These aren’t just restaurants—they’re stewards of tradition, each serving their own unique take on Florida’s most famous dessert.

Whether you’re visiting Florida or you’re a local ready to treat yourself, these ten spots will take your key lime pie game to the next level.

Blue Heaven – Key West

At Blue Heaven, you’ll find roosters roaming around the garden, but the real star here is their legendary key lime pie. This slice of heaven comes topped with a towering swirl of toasted meringue that’s practically Instagram-famous. The filling is perfectly balanced—just the right amount of tartness from real key lime juice. Combine that with the laid-back, quirky vibe of Key West, and you’ve got an unforgettable experience.

Pepe’s Cafe – Key West

Pepe’s has been a Key West staple since 1909, and their key lime pie is as classic as it gets. The creamy filling paired with a crumbly graham crust and a dollop of whipped cream will make you feel like you’ve stepped back in time. They’ve been perfecting this recipe for over a century, and it shows. Every bite is a slice of Florida history.

Joe’s Stone Crab – Miami Beach

Joe’s may be famous for its stone crabs, but their key lime pie is just as legendary. Served chilled, the creamy, zesty filling is paired with a crunchy crust that’s pure perfection. The elegant atmosphere makes it feel like a special treat—perfect for celebrating or just savoring a little slice of Florida’s citrusy heritage.

S.S. Wreck and Galley Grill – Marathon

If you’re in Marathon, don’t miss this waterfront gem. The key lime pie here at S.S. Wreck is all about balance—a smooth, tangy filling with a perfectly structured crust that doesn’t overpower the lime flavor. The casual, laid-back atmosphere by the water only adds to the charm. It’s the kind of place where every bite feels extra special.

The Green Turtle Inn – Islamorada

The Green Turtle Inn has been serving up its unique twist on key lime pie since 1947. Their version comes with a macadamia-nut rice crispy crust and a topping of coconut whipped cream with berry syrup. It’s a creative spin that still honors the classic flavors while adding a little extra flair. A must-try for anyone passing through Islamorada.

Latitudes – Key West

For a more upscale experience, Latitudes delivers key lime pie with a side of elegance. Think fluffy meringue, a drizzle of blueberry sauce, and fresh berries on top. The refined presentation matches the sophisticated vibe of the restaurant, making this pie feel like a fine dining dessert. The flavors are spot-on, too—sweet, tart, and totally unforgettable.

Kermit’s Key Lime Shop – Key West

Kermit’s keeps it simple, and that’s why it works. Using authentic key limes (not the cheaper Persian limes you’ll find in knockoff versions), their pie has a bright, tangy flavor that’s impossible to beat. With locations across Key West, it’s easy to grab a slice—or even take one home. No frills, just perfection.

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company – Cocoa Beach

The Florida Key Lime Pie Company is a fun, tiki-inspired spot in Cocoa Beach is famous for their award-winning key lime pie. Creamy, smooth, and perfectly balanced, it’s the kind of dessert you crave on a beach day. They even offer pie-on-a-stick for a playful twist that’s great for strolling along the coast. It’s a slice of pure Florida fun!

Yoder’s Restaurant – Sarasota

Yoder’s brings a homemade, comforting touch to their key lime pie. The bright lime flavor and flaky crust make it feel like something your grandma might have made… if she lived in Florida, that is. This Sarasota favorite proves you don’t need to be in the Keys to find a killer key lime pie.

But don’t stop at the key lime! Yoder’s serves up a wide variety of pies that will make your decision deliciously difficult. From the classic cream pie to their peanut butter pie, there’s a slice (or two) for every craving. Good luck picking just one!

Great Southern Cafe – Seaside

Great Southern Cafe’s key lime pie is award-winning for a reason. Topped with toasted almonds and whipped cream, it’s a creative take that still respects the classic flavors. Located along Florida’s Gulf Coast, this pie combines tradition with a little extra texture and fun. It’s the perfect end to a meal by the beach.

Planning Your Key Lime Pie Adventure

Florida is home to an incredible variety of key lime pie, and each spot on this list offers something unique. Whether you’re a fan of traditional recipes or you’re looking for creative twists, there’s a slice out there for you. Authentic key lime pie should always use real key lime juice for that distinctive tangy flavor, and the filling should be a perfect balance of tart and sweet. Whether it’s topped with meringue, whipped cream, or nothing at all, the best versions highlight Florida’s citrusy soul in every bite.

So, go ahead—plan your Florida key lime pie adventure and treat yourself to this iconic dessert. Your taste buds will thank you!