20 Best Pizzerias in Orlando, Florida
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Orlando, look no further! There are plenty of options to choose from when it comes to finding your favorite slice.
From classic New York-style thin crusts to Chicago deep dish pies and everything in between, there’s something for everyone’s taste buds.
Here are a few of our top picks:
1. Flippers Pizzeria
- Address: 11062 International Dr, Orlando, FL 32821
Indulge in the delectable offerings of a laid-back pizzeria specializing in brick-oven pies and authentic Italian cuisine. Delight in the harmonious fusion of spices, flavors, and a hint of sweetness.
The Toscana breadsticks are an absolute crowd-pleaser, lovingly handcrafted and baked to perfection in a traditional brick oven.
2. NYPD Pizza
- Address: 9900 Universal Blvd #100, Orlando, FL 32819
Experience the magic of Universal Studios in Orlando, then take a leisurely stroll or a short drive to NYPD and indulge in their award-winning, authentic New York-style pizza.
In addition to an array of delectable pizza options, their menu boasts a diverse selection of authentic Italian cuisine. Indulge mouthwatering pasta dishes, savory calzones, and refreshing salads.
There are three locations in Orlando, one in Winter Garden, and a new establishment in Apopka. So there is likely a restaurant nearby to satisfy your pizza cravings!
3. Lil Vinny’s
- Address: 2200 Winter Springs Blvd, Oviedo, FL 32765
The pizza at Lil Vinny’s is consistently fresh and absolutely delightful. The staff is incredibly friendly, providing a warm and welcoming atmosphere.
Indulge in the authentic flavors of Italian cuisine while enjoying exceptional service that truly enhances the dining experience.
4. SoDough Square
- Address: 419 E Michigan St, Orlando, FL 32806
Introducing SoDough Square, conveniently situated in the vibrant SODO area (which stands for south of Downtown Orlando). The pizza and cheesy bread were absolutely phenomenal. I can already envision the rise of Detroit-style pizza, with its tantalizingly crispy edges and its delicate, airy crust that adds an extra layer of crispness.
5. Pienezza Pizza
- Address: 3236 John Young Pkwy, Kissimmee, FL 34741
Pienezza Pizza is a gem, with a-owned and operated vibe. Every dish was simply delightful! The chicken parm hero boasted a perfect balance of crispiness on the outside and tenderness on the inside. The chicken cutlets were thinly sliced, and the freshness of the ingredients really shone through.
This place is a must-visit if you’re craving authentic NY-style pizza and hero sandwiches.
6. Prato
- Address: 124 N Park Ave, Winter Park, FL 32789
Blending simplicity and inspiration, Prato celebrates cuisine from Italy’s rich culinary landscape.
The warm space welcomes guests with its contemporary design balanced by rustic elements, including a long bar that encourages a vibrant and communal atmosphere.
I adore the Mustard Spaghettini Cacio e Pepe and Diavolo pizza at this place! Their pizza dough and pasta are crafted daily with utmost freshness, resulting in flawlessly cooked dishes. Not to mention, the margarita pizza and meatballs on the menu are truly exceptional.
7. John & John’s – A Pizza Shop
- Address: 435 E Michigan St, Orlando, FL 32806
If you’re craving seriously delicious pizza, then John & Johns is definitely a must-visit. I started with the alla vodka pizza, which was simply divine. The sauce perfectly balanced creaminess and tanginess, while the crust was thin and crispy.
I also indulged in their signature upside-down pizza, a delightful twist on the classic. The toppings were generously piled high, and the addition of fresh basil provided a delightful burst of flavor. The pizza is exceptional, boasting bold and satisfying flavors. Whether you prefer a classic or more adventurous option, this place has something for everyone.
8. Tornatore’s Restaurant
- Address: 3818 Edgewater Dr, Orlando, FL 32804
Tornatore’s is a charming pizzeria that serves delicious pizza, pasta, wings, and other Italian favorites like chicken parmesan. Whether you have a specific craving or want a memorable dining experience, this place is an excellent choice.
Their signature pizza is a must-try. The classic combination of cheeses and spices creates a perfect harmony of flavor that will keep you coming back. The freshly made dough yields a wonderfully crisp texture. Generous and balanced toppings ensure a delightful blend of flavors.
9. Antonella’s
- Address: 360 W Fairbanks Ave, Winter Park, FL 32789
Antonella’s is not only known for their incredible pizza, but their stromboli and calzones are equally exceptional. The dilemma of choosing just one is a testament to the quality of their offerings.
This establishment offers both individual slices and whole pies of pizza, giving you the freedom to customize your own creation from an extensive selection of delectable toppings. Indulge in the ultimate pizza experience, tailored to your taste buds
10. Lazy Moon
- Address: 11551 University Blvd, Orlando, FL 32817
Lazy Moon is the perfect destination for college students, conveniently situated east of the University of Central Florida’s campus off University Boulevard. With their extended operating hours and an impressive selection of craft beers, not to mention their bocce league, Lazy Moon offers everything you could possibly desire from a pizzeria.
One of the highlights of Lazy Moon is undoubtedly the ability to indulge in their gargantuan 30-inch pizza, making it the perfect snack for game days.
They also offer delightful combinations, such as my favorite, the Boxcar Willy, which includes a slice of pizza paired with a refreshing pint of Pabst Blue Ribbon. This combination, in my opinion, is absolute perfection.
11. Pigzza
- Address: 1050 N Mills Ave, Orlando, FL 32803
Pigzza is a fantastic new addition to the neighborhood. The artichoke dip was incredible, although we needed another order of toast. Our server was more than happy to accommodate us.
While we enjoyed a variety of pastas, the real standout was the Casper white pizza. The flavors were terrific, and the crust was perfection itself.
12. Brick & Fire Pizza
- Address: 1621 S Orange Ave, Orlando, FL 32806
For some delicious appetizers and pizza, Brick & Fire Pizza
The bruschetta was divine, surpassing any I’ve ever had. We opted for the delectable combination of goat cheese with tomato jam. The pizza was a true delight and satisfied our cravings perfectly!
13. Piazza Italia
- Address: 9685 Lake Nona Village Pl #105, Orlando, FL 32827
Now, let’s talk about Piazza Italia, the next place on our list. Trust me, you’re going to adore it just as much as I do. Indulge in their delectable brick oven pizzas, fired with aromatic wood, that are simply unbeatable in terms of both taste and value.
The pies at Piazza Italia are truly exceptional. What sets them apart, in my opinion, is the use of imported cheeses from Italy and other ingredients like ham and prosciutto. This careful selection results in an authentic taste that is unmatched.
14. Buttercrust Pizza
- Address: 4781 S Orange Avenue, Orlando, FL
Buttercrust Pizza is a charming family-owned and operated establishment, proudly standing as the sole representative of its kind in Orlando.
If you crave the authentic taste of Detroit-style pizza, look no further than this hidden gem. Additionally, their oven-baked chicken wings provide a delightful alternative to the traditional fried variety, with a unique and tantalizing flavor.
15. Pizza Bruno
- Address: 3990 Curry Ford Rd, Orlando, FL 32806
Pizza Bruno in Orlando is undeniably one of the best pizza restaurants ever! Having made it to my lists before, their reputation for excellent food precedes them.
However, their pizza truly sets them apart, reaching an unparalleled level of deliciousness.
They serve the classic Neapolitan-style pizza here, the one that started it all. Their wood-fired pizza has that unbeatable flavor that transports you to Napoli where your taste buds will want to stay forever.
16. Broadway Pizza Bar
- Address: 403 Broadway, Kissimmee, FL 34741
This elegant pizzeria offers a delectable selection of specialty pies inspired by the vibrant flavors of New York City, along with a variety of other mouthwatering casual bites.
Located in a charming corner spot, the beautiful hardwood decor enhances the warm and inviting ambiance. The calzone, a true showstopper, surpassed all expectations with its generous size and bold flavors of spicy sausage and mushrooms. Don’t forget to order the garlic knots, because they are perfectly baked.
Every bite was a testament to the exceptional quality and taste. Absolutely delicious!
17. Pizza Xtreme
- Address: 7250 S Kirkman Rd #103, Orlando, FL 32819
This fast-casual joint offers self-service with drink cups provided upon entry. You won’t find a better-value meal in the area. The service is outstanding: fast and friendly, and the atmosphere is relaxed. It’s genuinely one of Orlando’s best hidden gems.
Now, let’s talk about the pizza. It’s simply perfection. The crust is crispy outside, while the cheese is soft and stretchy. The pizza toppings are delicious and fresh.
Their pizza outperforms any fast-food pizza chain in quality, value, speed, and portion. The $7 two-slice-and-drink option is my go-to, with several topping options.
18. Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant
- Address: 3210 E Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32803
Pizzeria Del-Dio is a cherished family-owned and operated gem, renowned for its genuine cuisine and exceptional service. I cannot emphasize enough the sheer excellence of their pepperoni pizza.
It is an absolute must-visit for all pizza aficionados. Unquestionably, it stands among the finest pizzerias in town — and without a doubt, it holds the top spot in my heart.
A cozy and relaxed eatery offering delicious NY-style pizzas along with hearty Italian pastas, meat dishes, and more. This is an authentic pizza place, born out of passion, not a generic establishment created by a disconnected entrepreneur.
19. Pizza 1905
- Address: 3717 Lake Emma Rd, Lake Mary, FL 32746
If you’re craving a mouthwatering deep dish pizza, look no further! This place is a culinary gem that will leave you in awe. The portions are generous, and even just one slice is enough to satisfy your appetite. Trust me, you’ll have delicious leftovers to enjoy the next day.
20. Pisa Pizza
- Address: 7058 W Colonial Dr, Orlando, FL 32818
This long-established counter-serve parlor offers made-to-order NY-style pizza in a humble setting. It’s truly the most delectable pizza I’ve ever tasted! A family-run business, they craft their pizzas and garlic knots with homemade crust, sauces, and fresh toppings, ensuring an unforgettable experience for your taste buds.
For more restaurants in Orlando, check out these guides!
